Categories
History

Instructions: Read the Analytical Essay 2.docx below to answer the questions pr

Swamped with your writing assignments? Take the weight off your shoulder!

Submit your assignment instructions

Instructions:
Read the Analytical Essay 2.docx below to answer the questions provided make sure to number them so it is clear which question you are answering.
Peer Review for Analytical Essay 2
First, read your peer’s paper, without making any comments….just get a general impression of the paper. Then, reread the paper and answer the questions below in detail. Your job is to provide constructive advice. Do not Simply write “good” or “yes” and “no” when revising your classmates papers. You must think about their work carefully in order to provide helpful comments to guide them in their revisions.
Rubric for Analytical Essay 2
Answer these questions and make sure to number them so it is clear which question you are answering.
1) Reread the assignment sheet. Evaluate below how closely your peer’s paper comes to meeting all of the requirements of the assignment? (Is the topic appropriate? Is it the required length? Are there the required sources? Etc.)
2) On the paper, write down what you think the thesis is. The thesis should be clear and arguable and not simply a statement of fact(s). Make suggestions for improving the thesis.
3) Does the paper make its case? Is the thesis supported with evidence and examples? Tell the writer where you would like more detail or more support.
4) As you read through the essay, did you ever feel lost or confused? Point out these places.
5) Evaluate the paper’s sources. Are they credible scholarly sources (for example, is Wikipedia a scholarly source?)
6) Evaluate the paper’s documentation of sources. Are all sources properly documented using the Chicago Manual of Style? Whenever the writer summarizes, quotes, or paraphrases, does she/he use a corresponding note? Does the note contain the correct details?
7) Make suggestions for improving the introduction and conclusion. The introduction (the first or first and second paragraphs) should interest the reader and set the stage for the rest of the paper. The conclusion should signal closure.
8) What are the paper’s strengths? What are its weaknesses? Make any final suggestions for improvements.

Swamped with your writing assignments? Take the weight off your shoulder!

Submit your assignment instructions

Leave a Reply